Pterrors of the Caribbean
By Deborah L. Davitt
Illustrated by Chaz Kemp
Part 2
Dominican Republic, 2170-Nassau 1721
As Ruby stood on the portal platform, and Quiang touched one final control, she had just enough time to wonder, Hey. If you’ve already been back in time, why haven’t you documented all of this—?
And then she was elsewhere and elsewhen. Except it wasn’t the right when at all. A stand of palm-roofed huts strung along a Caribbean shore, natives staring at her, their mouths agape as they reached for bows and arrows, and—wait a minute—three galleons, white sails belled out by the wind, making their way towards the island.
“God damn it, Quiang, you dropped me in time to sight the Nina, the Pinta, and the fucking Santa Maria—"
That was a shout into her communicator as Ruby ran, arrows arcing into tree trunks around her.
A curse in her ear, and then the world dissolved again. As it did, she wondered, Hey. What would’ve happened if I’d landed on one of the ships and just killed Columbus? Stopped colonization before it started? 
Quiang’s claim of being sidetracked to the Second Ice Age on the way to Egypt seemed entirely believable to her now. Time travel was clearly a tricky business.
He dropped her in the same location during the second Ice Age, to finish recalibrating. So she had time to study both her downloaded histories and his scans of the altered timeline. And while the suit kept her warm, the wind almost drove her mad.
And this time, when she appeared on target, it was in a noisome tavern. Right outfits for the era. Weirdly Appalachian accents on everyone’s English. “Excuse me,” Ruby said, getting right to work and drawing her stiller. “Has anyone seen any dragons?”
It took stilling the entire room and questioning one person at a time—for her to realize that she was closer to the pterosaurs, but at least a year too late. She learned the ‘dragons’ had been co-opted into use as an air force by the pirates. That Jack Rackham and Charles Vane were still alive, and both should’ve died long ago. Her text files, downloaded from the net before she left, confirmed that much. Guess this must be an alternate reality, after all. My files haven’t been erased. Unless there’s no such thing as paradox—oh, god, my head hurts thinking about this crap.
A quick message, this time tapped on the communications device. Hey. Closer, but still too late in the timeline. You need to move me further back. 1720, maybe earlier.
The only reply glowed in white text. Do your best. Can’t help right now.
Damn him. Ruby looked around the room. All these people, living in this reek of shit and piss and rotting food. Teeth decaying in their mouths, the rank smell wafting off them as she spoke with one or another.
The vids made the Golden Age of Piracy look like a grand adventure, and here, it just looked like every other ghetto in every other port town. Minus modern indoor plumbing. “You,” she said, waking another customer up out of stillness. “Where do I find Anne Bonny?”
A blank look of terror. “Come on, jizz-wits, I don’t have all day. Anne. Freaking. Bonny. Woman who wears pants, tamed dragons. Where is she?” Who knew that people in the past were all idiots?
A quaking hand pointed at a door at the rear of the tavern. Score! Okay, At least I get to meet Anne. “Don’t worry,” she told the man as she stilled him again. “It’ll all go back the way it’s supposed to be. You won’t even remember this. It’s better if you get the future you’re meant to have.” With indoor plumbing and global warming and even ChronoInnovation. Time travel is a blast, if we can get it away from the assholes.
And then into the room, and a click on the stiller, set to wide-dispersion. Ruby grinned and pulled up her camera feed, which went right through her retinas for all purposes except for selfies. “Score,” she muttered, looking around the room at the various men, caught mid-argument, and the single woman seated at the table with them. Then a rush of disappointment swept through her. Wow. She looks like she’s had one hell of a rough life. Are all those lines are her face just from sun-damage? Everyone here looks so freaking old. Maybe that’s all the disease and bad food? “Okay, Anne,” she said out loud. “Wakey-wakey time.”
Click.
Dominican Republic, 2170
Quiang sat back in his chair, satisfied. He watched the ghostly play of past events dance in the air as holograms. He’d seen this play out before, in archival footage that his superiors had shown him. He knew what was going to happen in that room.
Somehow, it was different, watching it play out in ‘real time.’ It was different, knowing that this time, it was the result of actions he’d already taken, not just actions that he’d been told he was eventually going to take. 
“I’m sorry, Ruby,” Quiang muttered, closing his eyes. 
There was a chance that the unthinking arrogance of the future, the tendency to assume that everyone in the past must think and feel as we do, because we’re so much better, smarter, more advanced, and of course right about everything, would falter. That she wouldn’t die for it. Fate wasn’t fixed; change was possible in a universe in which chaos existed, and realities could calve off from each other like icebergs.
But the chance of it happening here? Quiang knew it was vanishingly small.
“I’m sorry,” he repeated softly, like a mantra. “It has to happen. It’s already happened.”
Nassau, 1721
Anne had shifted on the bench towards the white-clad intruder, only to have the world fade out. When she regained consciousness, her vision returned slowly as her limbs came back to prickling, cramping life. She realized that she still sat by Jack’s side, but that the men remained still, almost frozen—Vane’s fist still in the air, about to thump the trestle table. 
The figure that had assailed them stood beside Anne, close enough that she could smell the acrid reek of its shining white clothing—trousers below, but without division between trews and shirt. 
It didn’t take a genius to understand that this figure, whoever it was, was a threat. It had paralyzed everyone in the room, as if by magic, and that, again, didn’t take a genius to connect to the presence of the flying beasts. Magic. And not Mackandal’s houngan business, half Islam, half-African spellery. 
She, Jack, and the others had spent many long nights over grog, debating from whence the creatures had come. The local preachers would have it that they were demons straight from hell, a manifest sign of God’s wrath. Mackandal had called them spirits, either the loa of African tales, or the efreet of Arabian lore. “Either way, takes a person of great power, of great courage, to bind them, bargain with them,” he’d said, lifting his cup of water to her as if in respect. But his eyes had been wary. He’s afraid. Wants the secret, to take me and mine out of the business. Hold the power for himself. I can’t blame him. But I also can’t tell him or anyone else how the magic works. Else then they’d have no need for me and Jack, and our heads would be next on the wall. Can never let them know it’s just the magic of being a mother. Of being the first face the hatchlings see, of being the first hand to feed them. Nothing more. 
She and Jack had found identifying bands on all the adults that they killed. All with the same information, and the same, uncanny date. She didn’t understand what it meant. But she didn’t need to. All she needed was to understand them, her loveys. And how to use them in the world that they were making for themselves.
The figure reached up and lifted off its too-smooth helmet, and Anne tensed, then relaxed as a human female face appeared. Dark-toned skin suggested mixed descent, but the woman’s curly hair was vibrantly and unnaturally blue, and her features soft and unmarked as a child’s. “That’s better,” the intruder declared in an accent Anne could barely decipher. “So, you’re Anne Bonny? I’ve read all about you—”
“Anne Rackham,” she corrected, her tongue feeling thick in her mouth.
The intruder sighed, removing another square device from some pocket to take notes on it as if it were a piece of paper. “Another thing wrong with the time-line,” she muttered. “You actually married Calico Jack?”
“The day after my doltish husband died, aye.” Sensation had returned to Anne’s hands, but her feet remained numb. She didn’t think it best to announce this fact, but remained seated, discreetly worked her fingers by her sides, loosening them. People tended to underestimate her. She was small. Whip-slender. And a woman in a man’s world. “Seemed the thing to do, given that I was six months gone with child,” she added, still slurring her words, this time deliberately. She wanted time to figure out who this woman was. What she wanted. How she’d frozen them all in place like noddy dolls. Magic of another sort.
The woman’s eyes widened. “What? Anne Bonny, marrying because she was pregnant? But...you’re a feminist icon! You and Mary Read—you aren’t lovers in this timeline?” 
Timeline. Anne noted the word distantly, among the others she didn’t recognize, tucking it to the back of her mind for later, and then grimaced, moving her toes inside her boots. She remembered the news clippings and raucous ballads that had circulated even here, brought from England. “Lovers with Mary Read?” She laughed. “No. You do know that the English will print anything in their papers to make us sound more scurrilous than we really are, to keep people from helping us, aye? That printers make money by selling papers, and that nothing sells papers better than scandal?” She snorted. “Mary’s a good woman. Helps look after little Jack when I’m training the beasts to fly with us on their backs. Flies with us—has a good sense for moving with the beasts, not against them. Past that? Jack’s mine and I’m his.”
 The woman’s mouth fell open again, looking as piteous as a kicked pup. Anne wanted to slap her for her pleading eyes and face. What are you? You’ve taken us hostage, as surely as if you’d boarded our ship and held us under your guns. But you put on this show of weakness, and… think it strength? 
“None of this is right,” the woman said, sounding piteous. 
“You want to believe me, or what people who never met me have written about me?” Anne slurred carefully. “You’re a fool if you take rumor’s word for anything.”
“You...you were supposed to have a child in Cuba, that no one could ever find traces of, then plead your belly in 1720, when Jack was hanged, avoiding your own execution. None of this is right! I’ll bet that Vane and Blackbeard are still alive, too.” She sighed, oblivious to the turmoil now churning through Anne’s mind.
Vane’s supposed to be dead? I wouldn’t weep. Blackbeard was shot two years ago, up in Virginia…
The woman continued to mumble to herself, ignoring Anne. “I didn’t jump back far enough to find the initial incursion point. Tell me, when did the pterosaurs all start appearing? And where? I’ll get this fixed. You won’t even remember I was here.” She nodded briskly, her blue hair flying around her face. “I’ll hop forward to about 1725 to make sure that the timeline’s healed invisibly before heading for home.”
“I don’t understand.” Stalling. Playing for time. Trying to sound piteous and half-witted. Come on, witch. Buy the lie. It’s a good one.
The woman sighed. “I suppose there’s no harm in telling you. I mean, you won’t remember any of this.” She ran a hand through her knotted hair. “There’s a corporation in my time that’s colonizing the past. Breaking off alternate timelines for their resources, bringing them back to our timeline.” Her eyes blazed with enthusiasm, and she looked away, as if talking to an audience that Anne couldn’t see. “They’re gutting the multiverse! Getting fat on the blood of a hundred timelines, like a great, greedy tick! And it’s up to us to stop them. What do you say, Anne Bonny?” Her head swiveled back towards her, eyes wide, and something in them…glowing? Shining? “We’re going to put it all back the way it’s supposed to be,” she declared after an awkward pause in which Anne didn’t speak. “It’ll all be all right. I know exactly what to do. It’s what’s best, right?”
Anne shuddered at the sight, even as her mind worked feverishly behind her dull, glassy eyes. She could only grasp parts of the woman’s rapid speech, in which so many words were unfamiliar. So she’s…from the future. Why would people in the future breed dragons? Nevermind. Doesn’t matter. Her mind changed course, circled around the woman’s words. Supposed. Jack’s supposed to be dead. And if this witch from the future has anything to say about, I’ll open my eyes when she’s gone, and he will be. Supposed. Damned if I’ll bow to her yoke any more than to the Crown’s.
The next thought slammed through her like a cannonball. “So…when you’re gone…This entire last year won’t have happened?”
“Oh, no. Not the way it has, all screwed up. No pterosaurs. No coalition of pirates pissing off the French and freeing slaves…  though I suppose that’s sad. Don’t worry. They eventually get freed anyway.” But a shadow of a frown crept across the woman’s face, in spite of her cavalier, breezy words. “It’s for the best,” the woman insisted. “We know how it’s supposed to turn out. Anything else is, well…  it fucks up the whole world. Trust me.”
 Realizations hammered through Anne. I won’t have watched little Jack playing with the hatchlings. I won’t have ridden the beasts through the air, firing down on ships and laughing like a madwoman. The slaves won’t have joined with us, riding beside us through the air to attack Spanish outposts. I won’t have seen Jack’s face as he raises our child up into the air, his face alight as if he sees the future in his son’s eyes. Mackandal and his people won’t be free. None of it will have been. 
She swallowed convulsively, arriving at one undeniable conclusion within seconds. There will be no future worth having here, without these beasts. There will be no future worth having, without my son and husband in it.
Anne cleared her throat and stood, let herself sway a little. “Everything will just…. go back the way it was? I won’t remember this?” she asked, letting her right hand drift closer to her knife.
The woman approached to put a comradely arm around her shoulder. As if she had the right to touch Anne. She didn’t know Anne. She hadn’t earned that right, in tears and blood, the way Jack had.
“You won’t remember a thing,” she told Anne, commiseratingly. “But don’t worry—you won’t spend long in jail, and you’ll survive it. Why, I might—” she looked around furtively, “I might break the rules and leave you a note. Something that says a little about the future.” She raised her eyebrows conspiratorially. “Something like, you don’t need a man to be fulfilled or women can do anything they want to. What do you say?” She smiled, an arrogant, condescending smile that filled Anne with rage. “You ready to fix all this? Just tell me where and when the creatures started appearing.”
You’ll never let go of all your supposed. You undoubtedly have friends waiting for you. I wouldn’t go on a solo mission without backup within shouting distance. So I can’t let you shout…
“Didn’t get your name,” Anne mumbled, so softly that the woman had to lean in to hear her. Their faces almost touching. Smelling the weakness in the woman. Seeing the fascination in her eyes as the woman leaned in closer, almost as if she yearned for a kiss. You want me to be something I’m not, because it touches something inside you, she thought, keeping her lashes low, raising her left hand to the other woman’s shoulder as if for balance. Support. I mean something to you, because you’ve assigned me that meaning. And you want what I mean to you. Come here and take it. See how weak I am? 
“Ruby,” the woman whispered, bending closer. “But you won’t remember that, either—”
Anne’s right hand moved, slamming her knife into the woman’s throat, remembering making sure of her husband just this way. The crunch of cartilage, the grate of bone. 
The woman didn’t have a chance to trigger any of her equipment or alarms. She slumped in the circle of Anne’s free arm, but Anne pulled away from her, yanking her knife free as the woman fell. “You condescending bitch,” Anne whispered as the body spasmed at her feet. “What the hell makes you think I’m not doing exactly what I want to do?”
She wiped her knife off on the woman’s white clothes, and dug around for objects in the pockets. The notekeeping device, she read to the best of her ability, absorbing the information there about…them. All of them. Death dates for Jack, England, and Vane. Hornigold turning pirate-hunter, betraying them all, but dying in a hurricane…two years ago? Mackandal outliving all of them, only to be burned at the stake by the French in 1758. 
Her hands shook. And then she repeatedly stabbed the device with her knife, as if she could erase that future with her blade. No, she thought numbly. No. None of that is going to happen, because I won’t let it happen.
The rectangular device, she took. Have to thaw Jack, but god only knows what these buttons all do...Her hands shook. Then steadied as a wicked smile crossed her face, and she aimed the device at Vane. “If I accidentally witch you out of the world, where’s the bleeding harm?” Anne asked, and pressed buttons at random.
When Vane’s fist finally slammed into the table, Anne thawed the others, starting with Jack.
Her husband shook his head rapidly, looking around the room, his eyes lighting on the dead body. “What happened here?” Jack asked, sounding bewildered.
“The future is filled with weak idiots,” she replied, managing to snort. Bravado’s important. Let everyone see who's in charge. Who’s calm right now, and knows what’s what. “This one underestimated me.”
“People generally do,” he said, glancing at her. “Is...that one of their weapons?”
“I’ll be holding onto it,” Anne said, as the other captains at the table stirred. “This one was just a scout, belike. There will be more of them. Come to take their beasts back. To unmake what we’ve made. To ensure that you all die in what they consider your appointed times.” She pulled her lips back from her teeth, knowing now exactly what she had to say to unify them. To get them to all pull together, and fight these futurefolk. “You’re all supposed to be dead, she told me. Every one of you, hanged by Woodes Rogers. Most last year. Except you, Mackandal. You, the French are supposed to burn at the stake. Few years down the line.”
The woman didn’t have a chance to trigger any of her equipment or alarms.

She slumped in the circle of Anne’s free arm, but Anne pulled away from her, yanking her knife free as the woman fell. “You condescending bitch,” Anne whispered as the body spasmed at her feet.

“What the hell makes you think I’m not doing exactly what I want to do?”
It took some convincing. But eventually, jaws tensed, resolutions firmed. “I have no intention of letting that come to pass,” Jack said, biting the words off. “Who’s with me— no. Who’s with us?” He put a hand on Anne’s shoulder. 
Hands rose around the room. “Let’s get rid of this dross,” Anne said, kicking the body on the floor. “Somewhere out to sea, where they won’t know what hit her, when they come looking for her.”
“They could go back before she came, couldn’t they?” Hornigold asked, clearly struggling with the whole concept. 
“If they ever do—did—we wouldn’t be having this conversation now,” Jack pointed out, and then rubbed his head. “Let’s pull together, gentlemen. Because if we don’t, there’s no future for us. We all have one now, but only if we take it.”
Firm nods, and the men left, purpose in their steps. When they’d left, Jack gave her a look. “How much of that story was true?” he asked.
“Enough,” Anne replied tightly, her fingers wrapped around the white box so tightly that they ached. “Enough to know that soon we’ll be at war not just with the English, but with the future, too.”
Jack considered it, then nodded. “Let ‘em come.”
Earth, 2170 - 3274
Quiang monitored the signal until it went dead. If there’s a God, how he must despise us, his creations, for what we do.
Then pulled a different, much more advanced chrono-ingress device from a pocket. Set it for 3274 CE and activated it, just as the first fists hammered at the door of the portal room.
Stepping back through into his native time, he raised his hand in a salute to his superiors. “Did it go off as planned?” Colonel Mirlande Almasi asked him.
“It went off the way it had to,” Quiang replied, feeling tired and sick. “Because it already-always happened that way. Damn it.”
She put a hand on his shoulder. “It always feels like a betrayal.”
“Ruby wasn’t a bad person. Just…a product of her times. No sense of history as a thing that lives and flows—something that we’re all a part of.” Quiang swallowed. “But…it was always going to happen. Wasn’t it?”
 “Yes,” Almasi replied simply. “And it was always going to be you who sent her there. So that the alternate reality ChronoInnovations created could continue to exist. Just not exploited by that corporation. We’ve all been through this. We’ll get you through it, too.”
As Quiang headed down the long halls of Temporal Security Agency annex, he looked up at the screens that monitored billions of alternate timelines filled with people living out lives freed from control by the future, he had to believe that his actions guaranteed their freedom. Today, and in all his yesterdays and tomorrows. 
He had to.